Global Development: Views from the Center
« Aid Effectiveness: A Debate Between Steve Radelet and William Easterly | Main | More Health Workers, Yes. But Only Within Better Systems »
November 29, 2006
ABC's 20/20 Tonight: Are Americans Stingy or Generous?
Posted by David Roodman at 02:55 PM
At 10pm Eastern Time tonight, the U.S. television network ABC will air a feature by its in-house conservative curmudgeon, John Stossel. The theme: whether Americans are stingy or generous. Going by the web version, the story starts out being about how much the United States gives to poorer countries. As the conservative editorial page of the Wall Street Journal did in May (subscription required), Stossel cites the work of Carol Adelman of the Hudson Institute showing that as private citizens, Americans give more than many people appreciate: "We're one of the most generous people in the world, and that's because of our private philanthropy," she said.
(As my colleague Lawrence MacDonald asks, does this means I can go out and buy that flat-screen TV for Christmas guilt-free?)
Do you agree? I encourage you to vote on the ABC web site on whether Americans are generous or stingy.
One problem with the Adelman argument that I've pointed out before is that it make America look good by not comparing it to anything. Even using Adelman's debatable figures, Americans give 66 cents per person per day to the poorer four-fifths of the world. Is that generous? I'll let you judge.
ABC did contact CGD in the production of this story, showing interest in the post-tsunami debate between Adelman and CGD senior fellow Steve Radelet, and in the Commitment to Development Index, which factors in government tax incentives for private charity, among many other things. Notably, the experts actually cited in the story (as distinct from the movie and rock stars) all come from one particular part of the political spectrum.
And as for the ongoing voting, this is one election ABC did not hesitate to call before the polls close: "America," Stossel and coauthor Gena Binkley write, "is anything but cheap."
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
/mt/mt-tb.cgi/706
Comments
The argument about whether America's "stinginess" is offset by American's "generosity" is a distraction from the real questions about the role of this country. It's worth thinking for a moment about a statement by Canadian philosopher John Ralston Saul: "Indeed you can usually tell when the concepts of democracy and citizenship are weakening. There is an increase in the role of charity and in the worship of volunteerism. These represent the élite citizen's imitation of noblesse oblige; that is, of pretending to be aristocrats or oligarchs, as opposed to being citizens."
Posted by: Ruth Levine at November 30, 2006 10:34 AM