Michael Clemens

 
Michael Clemens
Profile
Research Fellow Michael Clemens leads CGD’s Migration and Development initiative. This work investigates how rich countries’ regulation of international movement by people from poor countries shapes the lives of the people who move as well as those who do not.


Full Bio
http://www.cgdev.org/content/expert/detail/2570/

Posts:

 

March 18, 2010

Why a Careful Evaluation of the Millennium Villages Is Not Optional

By Michael Clemens

Michael ClemensThe Millennium Villages Project (MVP) is a new, large, experimental intervention to promote economic development in 13 clusters of small and very poor villages across Africa. It has been driven forward by Jeffrey Sachs, one of the world’s foremost economists, and today is a joint effort of Columbia University, Millennium Promise, and the United Nations. The project deploys a broad package of interventions for five years in each village, including distribution of fertilizer and insecticide-treated bednets, school construction, HIV control, microfinance, electric lines, road construction, piped water and irrigation lines, mobile phones, and several others. Its goal is to break the villages out of poverty traps and build a “solid foundation for sustainable growth”.

Over the years I’ve been critical of the Millennium Villages, in soundbites trotted out periodically by the Financial Times and New York Times. Here I want to explain what lies behind those soundbites. I hope the MVP will consider these points as they revise their evaluation practices this year and continue to scale up the project. Read More…

8 Comments »

 

March 3, 2010

Three Cheers for Colombian Court’s Upholding Presidential Term Limits

By Michael Clemens

On Friday the Constitutional Court of Colombia ruled that President Alvaro Uribe cannot change the constitution (again) to seek an additional term as president.  This is a victory for Colombia’s long-term development, regardless of how good a president Uribe is.  It is an example to the entire developing world.

Last year I worried that Colombia would fall into the same trap that so many other developing countries have—endlessly changing the constitution to keep popular leaders in office.  So many countries have done this that it would not be an exaggeration to call it a plague.  In Africa alone, it has happened twelve times in the past decade.  Colombia deserves better.  I lived in Colombia and love the country, and I want it to realize its vast potential. Read More…

3 Comments »

 

January 25, 2010

Reactions to My Proposal for a New Visa to the United States

By Michael Clemens

Yesterday in the Washington Post I proposed a new kind of visa, a Golden Door Visa. It would ensure that at least a few of our immigration slots go to people from the poorest countries, such as Haiti, people who need opportunity the most.

Predictably, I’ve been flooded with vicious personal attacks, both private and public. My inbox has burst with emails like this one, whose author concealed his or her identity:

Read More…

11 Comments »

 

January 11, 2010

Development in the Year of Immigration Reform: New Video

By Michael Clemens

How can someone outside Haiti raise the income of a person who is very poor in Haiti? The fastest, surest, biggest way is simply to let that person work outside Haiti for some period, in a rich country. My co-authors and I document that a 35 year old urban male with some secondary schooling, born and educated in Haiti, earns a standard of living at least six times greater on average in the United States than the same person earns in Haiti. Read More…

1 Comment »

 

December 10, 2009

Prescription for Hypocrisy: The Tough Ethics of International Doctor Migration

By Michael Clemens

The British Medical Association just released a new statement on the international migration of health workers. Sadly, it repeats a common, self-contradictory, profoundly unethical position on international high-skill migration.

It starts off well. The Association states that “every health professional has a right to migrate to seek work wherever they wish for professional or personal reasons”, and thus “measures to restrict the movement of health personnel may be unethical.” How magnanimous for a professional guild to seemingly favor competition from abroad! Read More…

1 Comment »

 

June 22, 2009

One Small Way to Fix the World: Welcome Guest Workers

By Michael Clemens

Welcome Guest WorkersIf you could do one thing to make the world a better place, where would you start? The current issue of The Atlantic suggests fifteen ways to fix the world. One of them, which you’ll hear a lot more about in the year to come, is from the always-brilliant Kerry Howley: Welcome guest workers. Read More…

1 Comment »

 

June 4, 2009

Beyond the Fence: Fresh Ideas on How Immigration Policy Shapes Global Development

By Michael Clemens

Next week, President Obama will meet with Congress to begin discussing changes in the way that the United States regulates who can enter this country and what they can do here. The elephant in the room: global development. U.S. immigration policy transforms the lives of low-income people from all over the world, but you won’t hear much about them. Read More…

2 Comments »

 

May 21, 2009

Don’t Do It, Colombia! Presidential Term Limits Are Good for Development, But Endangered

By Michael Clemens

How long should presidents rule? On Tuesday, Colombia’s senate approved a national referendum to amend the constitution—again—to allow the popular president Alvaro Uribe to stand for election next year to yet another term in office. Read More…

2 Comments »

 

February 17, 2009

Solve the Crisis by…Kicking Out the World’s Best and Brightest?

By Michael Clemens

The global economic crisis is already creating pressure for the United States to further restrict skilled migration. The economic stimulus act that President Obama signs today limits the ability of many companies receiving stimulus money to freely employ highly skilled foreign workers on H-1B visas. (Read the Act yourself here.) In other words: If we can just kick out of the United States enough bright and highly skilled workers, many of them top U.S.-trained students from developing countries, the crisis will somehow ease.

Read More…

8 Comments »

 

October 31, 2008

Glaring U.S. Absence at the Global Forum on Migration and Development

By Michael Clemens

I spoke this week at the Global Forum on Migration and Development here in Manila, at both the government meetings and the civil society days. I came here to highlight the many policy questions about migration and development that can’t even be asked until we have better data on human movement. As I’ve carped about before, it is much easier to gather statistics on the cross-border travels of coffee beans and toothbrushes than it is to count the international movement of maids and physicians.

Read More…

1 Comment »

 

October 3, 2008

One of The Biggest Blind Spots in Global Development: Data on Movement

By Michael Clemens

Doing research on migration and development is tough. Some of the most basic questions can’t even get off the whiteboard because data on migration are so limited. If the government of Kenya wants to know how many doctors went last year from Nairobi to London, or vice versa, no one can tell. If a hard-working economist wants to know how many Pakistanis have temporary labor contracts in the Gulf countries, good luck.

Read More…

1 Comment »

 

September 22, 2008

Crisis? Not If We Take a Long View (Development Impacts of Financial Crisis)

By Michael Clemens

Michael ClemensWhen you’re done reading today’s news stories about the crisis, take a deep breath. Media coverage is focused on the very short term, as usual. Speculation abounds that we live in a different world now. I’m reminded of portentous claims after the Asian Financial Crisis that “the miracle was over”, claims which look very overwrought in hindsight. In historical perspective, many of the most worrisome recent crises are small bumps on a very long road.

Read More…

5 Comments »

 

September 8, 2008

Migration and Development: CGD Visiting Fellow John Gibson Wins NZIER Economics Award

By Michael Clemens

Jon GibsonJohn Gibson, CGD visiting fellow, has been given the prestigious Economics Award of the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research.

In my circles John is best known for his pioneering work on the New Zealand visa lottery with David McKenzie and Steven Stillman — arguably the best natural experiment in economic research on migration and development. This paper is now forthcoming in the Journal of the European Economic Association. It is the first successful attempt in economics to measure the true, pure effect on the wages of someone from a poor country from working in a rich country, purged of all migrant “selection” by a brilliant research design.

Read More…

Comment »

 

August 25, 2008

Do You Have Your Job because of Your Merit or Your DNA? For Many Migrants from Poor Countries, DNA Makes the Difference

By Michael Clemens

If you’re not a black person, suppose you were. Suppose you were also born in New Orleans’ Lower Ninth Ward, which was already in poverty before it was devastated by Hurricane Katrina. So you sought to better your life by getting a job in Chicago. But then US government officials forced you not to take the job, because DNA tests proved that you are not closely related to any white person.

Read More…

2 Comments »

 

August 5, 2008

If Congress Admits More Foreign Nurses, Will It Be Responsible for Killing Children in Poor Countries? Think Again.

By Michael Clemens

A subcommittee of the U.S. Congress has just approved a bill that would let modestly more foreign nurses work in the United States. New York Times reporters are concerned that measures like this, by encouraging movement of nurses out of developing countries that need them, could literally kill children. Today, the World Health Organization agrees that health worker movements contribute to disease and death in poor countries.
Should you be outraged at our government? Should our representatives who encourage nurse migration be locked up alongside the murderous Radovan Karadzic, as a stunning article in the respected medical journal The Lancet asserts?
The debate on this topic often misses three big facts: 1) Blocking the movement of developing-country professionals does certain harm to them, 2) supposedly softer measures like overseas recruitment restrictions tend to block movement just like migration barriers, and 3) there is no scientific evidence that restricting their movement by force can meaningfully affect the health problems devastating many poor countries. Without such evidence we should be very hesitant to take strong steps that prevent overseas health workers from accessing the very high-paying jobs that Americans take for granted by birthright. I’ll discuss recent research on these three points.

Read More…

1 Comment »

 

July 1, 2008

On Zimbabwe: How Do the Worst Leaders Affect Development?

By Michael Clemens

One of the great underexplored areas in economic development research is rigorous investigation of how bad leaders affect development. A series of actions by Robert Mugabe’s regime have coincided with an epic collapse of Zimbabwe’s economy, erasing half a century of income growth and bringing on four million percent inflation. In a country where large numbers of poor people live on the edge of subsistence, such a collapse is likely to cause large numbers of deaths. But how can we really know that Mugabe is the cause of his people’s ills, when his mouthpieces claim that drought or shadowy foreign meddling is at fault? Read More…

2 Comments »

 

May 27, 2008

Let’s Do the Numbers: CGD Launches Commission on Migration Data for Development Research

By Michael Clemens

What is the biggest distortion in the world economy? A forty-percent price gap for identical widgets traded in two different markets is considered large these days. In capital markets, investors would be shocked by a price difference of one percent for the same security in two different exchanges. But in the global labor market, wage gaps for equivalent workers differ between countries by one thousand percent or more in some cases.

Read More…

1 Comment »

 

January 28, 2008

The Best Provocative, Short Read on Migration And Development

By Michael Clemens

Harvard professor and CGD colleague Lant Pritchett has given a stunning interview to Reason magazine that will be a revelation if you haven’t yet been exposed to Pritchett’s incandescent ideas on migration and development. Below are selected quotations from Pritchett in the interview.

Read More…

2 Comments »

 

January 11, 2008

Media Reports on African ‘Brain Drain’ Misunderstand My Research

By Michael Clemens

This week I watched with a queasy stomach as my own research was widely reported in support of a belief that is the exact opposite of my findings. Citing a new journal article of mine, yesterday the BBC trumpeted that Africa is “being drained of doctors”, and a separate story on BBC’s French-language service implied that health professional emigration is directly responsible for deaths of Africans. (Radio France did a better job.)
All that my study says is that roughly 30% of sub-Saharan African-born doctors work outside Africa. For registered nurses it’s closer to 15%.
I can understand why people might make the huge jump from these numbers to believing that there are deleterious staffing and health consequences for Africa. But don’t do it. Let us do here what the reporters didn’t have the time or interest to do: think clearly and carefully about the links between these numbers and the consequences for Africans.

Read More…

11 Comments »

 

December 6, 2007

Buy a Beer in Zimbabwe — You’ll Need It

By Michael Clemens

What’s it like to live in a country whose economy has been shattered by its own leaders? Here’s how a beer purchase in Zimbabwe looks these days:


That’s $1 million Zimbabwe dollars, in four chunky packs of Z$500 notes–collectively, the price of a single beer purchased at a bar in Harare on November 24th. When the beer was quaffed, at the “official” (read: “fantasy”) exchange rate, that was about US$33. At the “black” market exchange rate, that was just under US$1. Today, just twelve days later, it’s only worth around twenty five US cents. Such an economic Twilight Zone forces anyone running a business with the smallest international component to choose between illegality and immediate closure.

Read More…

Comment »